Hello, Win Column!
Tksymm7 said:
ABS has been a smashing success so far I'd say
Tksymm7 said:
100% my angle as well. No one cares much if you miss a call here or there. No one is perfects it's the attitude and arrogance that I'm glad is being taken down.
There are moments that offer a pretty good sense that something new is going to work. This feels like one for ABS. The Cincinnati crowd’s reaction was thunderous. And the situation itself — twice it salvaged a bases-loaded opportunity. This system plays. pic.twitter.com/vS0TYzBX6H
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) March 29, 2026
Great stuff. Similar to how tennis works, but more exciting since there's a home crowd.dave94 said:
This is awesome stuff re: ABS and the umps getting their just dessertsThere are moments that offer a pretty good sense that something new is going to work. This feels like one for ABS. The Cincinnati crowd’s reaction was thunderous. And the situation itself — twice it salvaged a bases-loaded opportunity. This system plays. pic.twitter.com/vS0TYzBX6H
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) March 29, 2026
BCSWguru said:
The ABS is good so far. Will say I am not a huge fan of these balls that catch 1mm of the zone or missing the zone by that much getting overturned. I realize technically the calls are made correct, but blaming the umpire for missing these terribly close calls will have a long term negative effect I'm sure. I do like it will expose the Bucknor and West and Hernandez of the lot. Those guys suck(ed).
AggieEP said:BCSWguru said:
The ABS is good so far. Will say I am not a huge fan of these balls that catch 1mm of the zone or missing the zone by that much getting overturned. I realize technically the calls are made correct, but blaming the umpire for missing these terribly close calls will have a long term negative effect I'm sure. I do like it will expose the Bucknor and West and Hernandez of the lot. Those guys suck(ed).
I think for an overturn making a ball a strike the standard should be that at least 20% of the ball should clip the zone. As enforced right now, the strike zone just expanded by 3 inches in all directions.
The standard for a strike to be a ball on overturn is 100% of the ball outside the zone, I think for the inverse 100% of the ball inside the zone would be too extreme, but 20% feels fair to both the pitcher and the hitter.
double aught said:
DIRECTV stream works well. Never had any issues. Good interface.
Vessel said:AggieEP said:BCSWguru said:
The ABS is good so far. Will say I am not a huge fan of these balls that catch 1mm of the zone or missing the zone by that much getting overturned. I realize technically the calls are made correct, but blaming the umpire for missing these terribly close calls will have a long term negative effect I'm sure. I do like it will expose the Bucknor and West and Hernandez of the lot. Those guys suck(ed).
I think for an overturn making a ball a strike the standard should be that at least 20% of the ball should clip the zone. As enforced right now, the strike zone just expanded by 3 inches in all directions.
The standard for a strike to be a ball on overturn is 100% of the ball outside the zone, I think for the inverse 100% of the ball inside the zone would be too extreme, but 20% feels fair to both the pitcher and the hitter.
I don't see it this way. The way I learned it, any part of the ball in the zone is a strike. If the ball barely clips the black of the plate, it is a strike. It logically follows that the same would apply to the upper and lower boundaries of the zone.