While I haven't stayed at the one in Cancun, my thoughts would be that one.
While there is nothing wrong with this one, I think it's good for 3-4 days. Pretty quiet. 18-19 palapas total on the beach. Food had been decent but not what I would expect for this caliber resort.
They have:
Buffet for breakfast and dinner
Sit down for lunch
Two snack bar type options for lunch
Italian, Asian (only open certain days), Mexican/mixed and buffet for dinner.
Open air lobby, and lunch/dinner at Lola's is outdoors. So I can see this being quite hot in the summer months.
Service is a little slower than I like. But I'll admit I'm spoiled.
There is nothing wrong with this resort and it's a good option for the price point. I do really like the pool, and the beach was way better than I was expecting. Sports bar played all the college football Saturday so that was better than most resorts I've been to in the fall. We were even able to get it in our room and I'm not sure that's happened before at any resort I've been to.
I would stay here again but would also probably try new resorts over coming back. Again I think it's a great option for 4 nights or so.
Haven't tried any of the nightly entertainment other than the one night they had the violinist in the lobby.
I'll ask but I don't think they have any non-motorized water sports which should be a staple for this caliber resort. Website says "coming soon" but it's been open 10 months. I see no places for it either.
They are at 41% occupancy, so pretty low. They said 50% on the weekends.
I think what I'm most disappointed is I got what I thought was a really nice oceanview balcony room.
This is my view sitting down. The rooms with smaller bathrooms and a regular table/chairs have a far better view than I do. I can see the ocean standing up.
Note I'm probably pickier than most since I've stayed at quiet a few resorts. This is certainly not a bad option and I would totally sell it to others. I had 2 couples stay here in Feb and loved it (4 nights).